Posts

Showing posts with the label faq

FAQ U: What's the Phallus?

The phallus is masculine in the same way a penis is masculine. I wrote a primer on Lacan’s concept of phallic desire a month ago, and I realize—although my blog is mine and my target audience is one at least superficially familiar with concepts from Marxism and Freudian psychoanalysis, so I don’t feel particularly motivated to write introductions for people totally new to those fields of discourse—I kind of did that XKCD bit about how familiar the average person is with niche obscure bullshit. Again, it’s not my problem necessarily, but then people talk about how literal or abstract the phallus notion is supposed to be from Lacan’s mouth or my own. Is the phallus masculine (to quote WFS ) “the way a horse [think equus in Latin] is masculine”? Is classic D&D more “literally phallic” (by way of being masculinely horny) than I had “intended” in my critique of it ? Is usage of the word “phallus” a mere birthmark of a discourse originally grounded in bioessentialism from which it...

FAQ U: What Is Phallic Desire?

Image
Dear Reddit: am I the asshole? I jumped into a conversation on the OSR discord about how people often write TTRPG adventures (or texts more broadly, I think) with such a utilitarian mindset geared towards play that they often neglect to write anything actually interesting or pleasurable to read—you know how often the pendulum swings one way or the other. This inspired something in me, so I was like “Yeah!!! And isn’t that the fun part anyway?” Some people agreed, but for the most part it was like that reaction picture of girls staring at you because you said something weird at a party, but instead of girls it’s a bunch of sweaty guys because I forgor what server I was in (no offense— the OSR will be the OSR ). I thought it was a bit and then I kept posting Lacan’s sexuation table as if to point fingers and be like “MALE!” (boom) “PHALLIC!” (boom) “CASTRATED!” (boom) Oh God. I am the asshole. Shit. Fuck. Damnit. But I thought it was interesting when I DM’d someone about it and was lik...

FAQ U: Plagiarism, Part II

There’s a professor at my partner’s graduate school who’s very eager to catch students in the act of academic dishonesty. The class is split up into small groups to write and present a review article of publications in the field. Like clockwork, every year, the students who write the actual data summary for their respective groups’ projects get called to his office to beg for academic probation (as opposed to expulsion). Why? Because their portions of the project have undeniable similarities to published works as detected by the professor’s anti-plagiarism software. You might notice the problem here. Those students wrote the data summary section of their review articles—the section where you cite, quote, and summarize existing literature to contextualize the more analytical sections of the review. Every year, a handful of poor students get slapped on the wrist by the professor but then are quietly freed by the dean who has seen this happen every year and has a smarter head on her shou...

FAQ U: Why Am I Here?

Image
New year, new me? Sorta kinda . I've found myself recounting the same origin story to multiple people multiple times, so I thought that I would put it on record so there's no surprises anymore. I think I was first aware of D&D because of my dad, who played some sort of AD&D in the early eighties. Didn't know or understand much of it from him, except that it was a game where you hunted for treasure or something like that. It was more interesting to me that he stuck up for D&D but didn't let us watch Harry Potter because it was satanic—whereas we had Chick Tracts condemning both. It didn't really affect me, though. I don't think I saw the appeal in either, at the time? Now I have a good reason to avoid Harry Potter lol. Anyway. Flash-forward to my junior year of high school. My best friend (now partner!) got really into an actual play podcast called The Adventure Zone , based on D&D Fifth Edition . The McElroy Brothers, who were popular from th...

FAQ U: What is Plagiarism?

For a while, I’ve had a big theoretical post about art in my drafts—not that I think my own thoughts are that important, but that it was something I wanted to explore for myself. This post anticipates that draft, but it’s also a response to people who were confused by my dual position from that article a few weeks ago: (a) that I’m a communist and don’t respect copyright or intellectual property, and (b) that I think plagiarism is both disrespectful and unethical. If I oppose intellectual property, why does it matter if someone violated someone else’s intellectual property? The short answer is that it’s not a question of intellectual property, but one of creative integrity and appropriation. I often pirate game materials and other things, to read and share with others. No one thinks I wrote any of it, and I’m making no money. The opposite is true when it comes to commercial plagiarism like the case study from earlier this month: the author printed other people’s work as her own, and...

FAQ U: What is a Blorbo?

https://www.tumblr.com/hashtagloveloses/709450126123466753/it-seems-people-dont-understand-a-glup-shitto-is This is a friendly response to my friend Sandro's post about blorb vs blorbos ! Since people caught wind of the latter term in the TTRPG scene, there has been some confusion about what "blorbo" means—especially in how it relates to another term, "original character". Let me define both and try to go over the nuance between them. Original Character: A character someone makes up. Originally, it was in the context of fan fiction or forum role-play where the character is original with respect to the media property. However, in more recent usage, the characters could be detached from any property whatsoever and are just conceptually fun characters that the creator likes to imagine. Blorbo: Someone’s absolute favorite character from a work of media, that is, one over which they’re completely obsessed. The original phrase “ blorbo from my shows ” is about a hy...

FAQ U: What is Fascism?

Image
I seem to have stepped into some shit when I published Fantastic Medieval Campaigns. The olds were, as expected, aghast at the (not so) “secret postface”. This was on one hand because they were mad that someone put politics in their elf game—such that there are “depoliticized” copies of the PDF floating around online, which is deeply hilarious and stupid if not also poetic. On the other hand, there were more “educated” complaints that I invoked a vulgar notion of fascism detached from historical context or specificity. I think this is an interesting topic to explore, since it is so contentious and revelatory of one’s own political perspective. “ The Fascist Manifesto ” (1919) This text is short enough that I could replicate it here, actually. Italians! Here is the program of a genuinely Italian movement. It is revolutionary because it is anti-dogmatic, strongly innovative and against prejudice. For the political problem, WE DEMAND: Universal suffrage polled on a regional basis,...

FAQ U: Why Read Stalin and Mao?

Let’s just tally everything up. The most liberal estimates attribute about 8 million deaths to the Holodomor, the famine from 1932-3 in Soviet Ukraine under Stalin’s government. Just under thirty years later from 1958-62, the Great Chinese Famine under Mao is said to have resulted in up to 55 million deaths (although counts from 35 to 45 million seem more common). Later, during the Cultural Revolution, the consensus among Western and Chinese historians seems to be that 2 million people had died. How about we combine all these for a nice, round number—like 65 million? Would anyone be mad if I said that the governments of the USSR and China under Stalin and Mao respectively resulted in the deaths of about 65 million people, give or take? Can we work with that? Simulated Knave asked a great question (I mean this sincerely), one which might be in the minds of many who come here for the D&D discussion and are then put off by the freaky communist shit: I’ve got to ask, as someone wh...

FAQ U: What is Marx's Critique of Value?

Sometimes, I (try to) talk about economics and end up bringing up a weird phrase: “social” value, or even “value” by itself. When I talk about social value, I refer to economic value, specifically following Marx’s critique of value in his Capital, Volume One [1]. You can read that volume for yourself, or read Marx’s seminar Value, Price and Profit where he discusses the concept in isolation [2]. I’ve also written about the implications of value in the context of so-called market socialism [3], or how the book Debt: The First 5,000 Years does not adequately account for value in discussing monetary units across history [4]. There was also an article I wrote a while back talking about value as a form of abstraction [5]. This is my attempt, though, to explain Marx’s critique of value in my own words, directly and not in the context of something else, in case some of you have not read Marx and want a simpler starting point than getting knee-deep in eighteen-hundreds (anti-)economics tex...